Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar in New York

"As a pizza lover, traveler, and experience person, this pizza by far is a 8 out of ten. The taste and flavor were spot on and the wings were cooked to perfection. I will most definitely be returning to this pizza spot when I return to the area. Tony's has great food!"

"I ordered 4 fish fries at 5:17 for pickup at 6:00. Easy ordering and payment online. Received a text few minutes later that my order was confirmed and would be ready. I received a second message closer to 5:50 that my order was ready for 6:00 pickup. Food was delicious! Could have been hotter but we were able to warm up at home. Only negative was the watery consistency of the tartar sauce."

"I stopped in on Wednesday and had such a great experience! Jen was my server and she was super polite, attentive, and welcoming from the start. She made an absolutely killer mocktail — seriously one of the best I’ve had! I came in pretty hungry and was so thankful for how fast the service was. My cheeseburger came out quickly and it was delicious. Everything hit the spot! Big thank you to Jen for making it such an enjoyable visit. I’ll definitely be back!"

"The buffet could use a couple more pasta dishes what was on there was very good but nothing like it shows in the picture desserts were only bought cookies a little disapointed with it but will go back and see if it is better! The server was excellent!"

"This was our first time there last night and the food was amazing. We didn't eat at the buffet we order off the menu and everything was fresh, the serving was big and delicious. Definitely going back especially to try the buffet."

"First time ordering from there tonight and I literally just got done eating and had to write a review because I’m telling you…these chicken wings were the BEST wings I have ever had, period! I ordered the tasty sauce and it did not disappoint. I’m a huge fan of chicken wings so believe me when I say they were the best!!!! They were fat, juicy, perfect amount of sauce and they were cooked to perfection! Whoever made these tonight thank you so much, you made my belly extremely happy!"

"The food here appears to be exquisite. I tell you, we got nothing like this here. The pizza and the buffet makes my mouth water. I hope to one day enjoy a meal here. My names Tony, I live in California, my family immigrated to this area from Germany and England, then in the 40’s and 50’s they went west in search of a new life. Many of my distant cousins remain in this area."

"Hi, We recently moved to the area. We found Tony's in Washington Mills. We started ordering pizza once a week, It's the BEST pizza!! We usually order Pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and red peppers. So flavorful and the crust is always perfect. This last Friday, we ordered the fish fry for the first time. I have to say it's THEE best Fish Fry we have had in years. It was so fresh, the batter just right, tartar sauce was homemade and delicious. The fries were cooked perfectly, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. It came with coleslaw and clam chowder soup- both were delicious.We are happy to have found this restaurant. Wendy Staff at the counter are always very friendly and efficient. I highly recommend Tony's Washington Mills. I wish I had taken pictures to post . Wendy"