Inside the Menu

At Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar, the menu offers a great mix of classic Italian flavors and hearty, satisfying choices that fit perfectly with a casual night out or a quick takeout. You’ll find everything from flavorful panini stacked with a variety of meats and cheeses to generous calzones and savory rolls, all made to order with fresh ingredients. There’s a nice balance between the comforting and the bold, with options like the Sicilian Pizza and Garlic & Pickle Pizza that add a unique twist. The menu moves naturally from starters and snacks, like their Garlic Wings, to more filling options like the panini and calzones. It’s easy to pick something to share while watching the game or grab a solid meal to enjoy on your own. Whether you’re in the mood for something light or more substantial, the menu has a bit of everything to satisfy different appetites and tastes.

Menu Sections (190)

  1. HH Mozzarella Sticks – $13.00

  2. 1/2 Order Greens – $18.25

  3. HH French Fries – $6.00

  4. HH Boneless Wings – $12.50

  5. HH Small (12") Pizza – $15.00

  6. HH Vodka Riggies – $18.95

  7. HH Dinings Meatballs & Long Hots – $15.00

  8. 2 Vodka Parm Garlic Knot Sliders – $11.00

  9. 3 Beef Empanadas – $11.00

  10. Chicken Quesadilla – $11.00

  11. Chicken Nacho Plate – $16.95

  12. Chicken Wing Dip – $11.00

  13. Bacon Cheeseburger w/ Garlic Parm Fries – $17.95

  14. Cheese Fries – $8.95

  1. Meatballs & Long Hots – $15.00

  2. Mozzarella Sticks – 8 sticks. choose your sauce: marinara, bbq, blue cheese, honey mustard. – $12.50

  3. Chicken Tenders – Choose your sauce: marinara, honey mustard, ranch, blue cheese, bbq or no sauce. – $13.00

  4. Boneless Wings – $12.00

  5. Sweet Potato Fries – $11.00

  6. Onion Rings – $11.00

  7. Greens Ala Tony – Escarole, garlic & spices, salami, prosciutto, hot soppressata, hot cherry peppers, onions, potatoes, romano & mozzarella cheese & breadcrumbs. – $18.00

  8. Jalapeno Poppers – $13.00

  9. French Fries – Fried potatoes. – $6.00

  10. Buffalo Chicken Fries – $15.00

  11. Fried Bologna & Long Hots – $12.00

  1. Large 2 Topping & 30 Bone In Wings – $56.00

  2. Large 2 Topping & 30 Boneless Wings – $51.00

  3. Large Cheese & 10 Boneless Wings – $32.00

  4. Large 1 Topping / Small 1 Topping – $34.00

  5. LG. Cheese 20 Boneless, LG Antipasto & 2 Liter – $53.00

  6. Small Pizza & 10 Bone In Wings – $27.00

  7. Small & 10 Boneless – $25.00

  8. Small Cheese & 20 Bone In Wings – $38.00

  9. Small Cheese & 20 Boneless Wings – $33.00

  1. Grilled Reuben & Fries – $18.75

  2. Friday Only : Jumbo Fish Fry – Only available on fridays: 11 oz. beer battered haddock, 1 pound fries, cole slaw, clam chowder. – $20.00

  3. 10 Oz. Sausage Patty – $15.00

  4. 10 Oz. Cheeseburger – Choose your veggies, dressing and cheese. lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles mayo, ketchup, mustard american, provolone, swiss, mozzarella – $16.50

  5. Thursday Spaghetti & Meatballs – Eat In Only – $10.00

  6. Calabrese Panini – Italian dressing, romaine, tomato, red onion, capicola, salami, hot soppressata, provolone, Italian giardiniera. Toasted. – $17.50

  7. Meatballa Parm Panini – Marinara, meatballs, black pepper, pecorino romano, mozzarella. Toasted – $17.50

  8. Roast Beef Panini – Horseradish mayo, onions, thin sliced roast beef, smoked gouda cheese, toasted – $18.75

  9. Steak & Greens Panini – Mayo, hot celery peppers. seasoned greens, Pecorino Romano, and mozzarella. Toasted – $18.75

  10. The Cubano Panini – Mustard, ham, pickles, roasted pork tenderloin, pepperjack cheese. Toasted – $18.00

  11. The Tony Panini – Layered breaded eggplant, marinara, roasted red peppers, artichokes, ricotta, peppers, mozzarella, pecorino romano. Toasted. – $17.50

  12. Tuscan Turkey Panini – Pesto mayo, italian dressing, iceberg, tomato, onion, sliced turkey, pepperoncini, roasted red peppers, provolone. Toasted. – $17.50

  13. The King BLT – $18.00

  14. The Beast Triple Decker – $27.00

  15. Fried Bologna & Long Hots – $12.00

  16. 2 Double Cheeseburger Meal – 2 double quarter pounder with cheese burgers. As is. Additional toppings need to be chosen if needed. Comes with a side of waffle fries. – $10.95

  1. Large (16") Cheese Pizza – $21.50

  2. Large (16") Garlic Pizza – $21.50

  3. Sicilian Style Crust Pizza – $21.50

  4. Large (16") Tomato Pie Pizza – $16.00

  5. Large Upside Down Pizza – $21.50

  6. Large Chicken Wing Pizza – $30.00

  7. Large (16") Mediterranean Pizza – Garlic base topped with baby spinach, roasted red peppers, artichokes, kalamata olives, fresh mushrooms, feta cheese, extra virgin olive oil & pecorino romano – $42.00

  8. Large Garlic & Pickle – Garlic base with mozzarella cheese and pickles – $28.00

  9. Large Five Cheese – Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, ricotta & pecorino romano on a light garlic base – $33.00

  10. Large The Amore – Sausage, hot cherry peppers, roasted peppers & onions – $34.00

  11. Large Stuffed Pizza – $42.00

  12. Small (12") Cheese Pizza – $15.00

  13. Small (12") Garlic Pizza – $15.00

  14. 12" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza – $21.50

  15. Small Upside Down Pizza – $15.00

  16. Small Chicken Wing Pizza – $20.00

  17. Small (12") Mediterranean Pizza – Garlic base topped with baby spinach, roasted red peppers, artichokes, kalamata olives, fresh mushrooms, feta cheese, extra virgin olive oil & pecorino romano – $28.00

  18. Small Garlic Pickle – Garlic base with mozzarella cheese and pickles – $19.00

  19. Small 5 Cheese Pizza – Mozzarella, cheddar, provolone, ricotta & pecorino romano on a light garlic base – $24.00

  20. Small The Amore – Sausage, hot cherry peppers, roasted peppers & onions – $24.00

  21. Small Stuffed Pizza – $25.00

  22. Tray Pizza (17X25) – All trays need a 2 hour notice to make & pick up – $42.00

  23. Tray Garlic Pizza – All trays need a 2 hour notice to make & pick up – $42.00

  1. 10 Wings – $15.00

  2. 20 Wings – $27.50

  3. 30 Wings – $41.25

  4. 40 Wings – $55.00

  5. 50 Wings – $66.00

  6. 100 Wings – $115.00

  7. Xtra Blue Cheese – $2.50

  8. Xtra Celery – $2.50

  9. Xtra Wing Sauce – $2.50

  1. Calabrese Panini – Italian dressing, romaine, tomato, red onion, capicola, salami, hot soppressata, provolone, Italian giardiniera. Toasted. – $17.50

  2. Steak & Greens Panini – Mayo, hot celery peppers. seasoned greens, Pecorino Romano, and mozzarella. Toasted – $18.75

  3. Meatballa Parm Panini – Marinara, meatballs, black pepper, pecorino romano, mozzarella. Toasted – $17.50

  4. Tuscan Turkey Panini – Pesto mayo, italian dressing, iceberg, tomato, onion, sliced turkey, pepperoncini, roasted red peppers, provolone. Toasted. – $17.50

  5. The Tony Panini – Layered breaded eggplant, marinara, roasted red peppers, artichokes, ricotta, peppers, mozzarella, pecorino romano. Toasted. – $17.50

  6. The Cubano Panini – Mustard, ham, pickles, roasted pork tenderloin, pepperjack cheese. Toasted – $18.00

  7. Roast Beef Panini – Horseradish mayo, onions, thin sliced roast beef, smoked gouda cheese, toasted – $18.75

  1. Large Turkey Sub – Please select what you would like on your sub. – $15.00

  2. Mixed Cold Sub – Please select what you would like on your sub. – $15.00

  3. Ham & Cheese Cold Sub – Please select what you would like on your sub. – $15.00

  4. Large Roast Beef – Choose dressing, veggies, cheese – $17.00

  5. Salami Cold Sub – Please select what you would like on your sub. – $15.00

  6. Cappy Cold Sub – Please select what you would like on your sub. – $16.00

  7. Pepperoni Cold Sub – Please select what you would like on your sub. – $16.00

  8. Prosciutto Cold Sub – Please select what you would like on your sub. – $17.00

  9. Tuna Cold Sub – Please select what you would like on your sub. – $15.00

  10. Veggie Cold Sub – Please select what you would like on your sub. – $15.00

  11. Chicken Caesar Wrap – Caesar dressing, romaine, red onion, grilled chicken, mozzarella, pecorino romano – $14.00

  12. Large The Italiano – Cappy, prosciutto, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion and Italian dressing. Topped with an gardinera Please select what you would like on your sub. – $16.00

  1. Large Meatball Parm – $16.00

  2. Large Chicken Parm – $16.00

  3. Large Chicken Club – $16.00

  4. Large Buffalo Chicken Sub – $16.00

  5. Large Chicken BBQ Sub – $16.00

  6. Large Eggplant Sub – $16.00

  7. Large Steak Sub – Grilled mushrooms, peppers, onions, shaved steak, mozzarella cheese. toasted. – $17.00

  8. Large BBQ Beef – $17.00

  9. Large BBQ Turkey Sub – $16.00

  10. Chicken & Greens Grinder Hot Sub – $17.00

  11. Large Steak & Greens Grinder – $18.00

  1. Cavatelli – $17.00

  2. Cheese Tortellini – Side salad & garlic bread – $17.00

  3. Chicken Riggies – Side salad & garlic bread – $17.95

  4. Gluten Free Chicken Riggies – $23.00

  5. Gluten Free Ziti – With marinara sauce. – $21.00

  6. Gnocchi – $17.00

  7. Hats – $17.00

  8. Jumbo Ravioli – Side salad & garlic bread – $17.00

  9. Manicotti – Side salad & garlic bread – $17.00

  10. Regular Rigatoni – $17.00

  11. Spaghetti & Meatballs – $17.00

  12. Stuffed Cheese & Spinach Rigatoni – Side salad & garlic bread – $17.00

  13. Stuffed Shells Pasta – Side salad & garlic bread – $17.00

  14. Ziti – Side salad & garlic bread – $17.00

  15. Vodka Riggies – $18.95

  1. Foot Long Calzone – Made to order foot long need 2 hour prep time. – $14.95

  2. Sausage Roll – Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time. – $28.00

  3. Antipasto Roll – Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time. – $33.00

  4. Broccoli Roll – Made to order Rolls & Trays need 2 hour prep time. – $28.00

  5. Chicken Wing Roll – Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time. – $30.00

  6. Ham & Cheese Roll – Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time. – $28.00

  7. Pepperoni Roll – Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time. – $28.00

  8. Spinach Roll – Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time. – $30.00

  9. Eggplant Roll – Made to order Rolls need 2 hour prep time. – $28.00

  1. Large Italian Antipasto Salad – $13.50

  2. Small Italian Antipasto Salad – $11.00

  3. Large Greek Antipasto Salad – $17.50

  4. Small Greek Antipasto Salad – $12.00

  5. Large Garden Salad – $13.50

  6. Small Garden Salad – $10.00

  7. Large Fresh Spinach Salad – Baby spinach, bacon, boiled eggs, fresh mushrooms, red onions, parm cheese, house croutons, topped with italian dressing – $15.00

  8. Small Fresh Spinach Salad – Baby spinach, bacon, boiled eggs, fresh mushrooms, red onions, parm cheese, house croutons, topped w/ house Italian dressing. – $11.00

  9. Large Chicken Caesar Salad – Romaine, red onion, eggs, croutons, fresh mushrooms, grilled chicken, pecorino romano, bacon. dressing: creamy caesar – $17.50

  10. Small Chicken Caesar Salad Small – $12.00

  1. Greens Ala Tony – Escarole, garlic & spices, salami, prosciutto, hot soppressata, hot cherry peppers, onions, potatoes, romano & mozzarella cheese & breadcrumbs. – $18.00

  2. Retail Antipasto – $9.00

  3. Mini Sausage Roll – $14.00

  4. House Soup – $6.00

  5. Fried Meatballs & Long Hots – $15.00

  1. Garlic Bread – $4.00

  2. Side Fries – $3.00

  3. Side Salad – $3.25

  4. Side Meatball – $2.00

  5. BBQ – $1.95

  6. Celery – $2.00

  7. Blue Cheese – $2.00

  8. Ranch – $1.95

  9. Mild Sauce – $1.95

  10. Medium Sauce – $1.95

  11. Hot Sauce – $1.95

  12. Marinara Sauce – $1.95

  13. Oil & Vinegar – $0.00

  14. SALSA – $7.00

  15. Tonys Bru Cheesa – $8.50

  16. Honey Mustard – $1.95

  17. Tasty Sauce (Everything Sauce) – $1.95

  1. Blueberry Crumble Cheesecake – $8.00

  2. Brownie – $5.00

  3. Cannoli – Crispy cannoli shell filled with homemade sweet ricotta cheese filling. – $5.50

  4. Chocolate Cake – $8.00

  5. Chocolate Cannoli – $6.00

  6. Peanut Butter / Choc. Pie – $8.00

  7. Peanut Butter Pie – $8.50

  8. Raspberry Cheesecake – $8.00

  9. Strawberry Cheesecake – $8.50

  10. Tiramisu – $7.50

  11. Toasted Almond Cream Cake – $7.50

  12. Blueberry Lemon Cake – $7.00

  13. Rice Krispy Square – $3.50

  14. David's Gluten Free Brownie – $4.75

  15. David's Gluten Free Brookie – $4.75

  16. Pistachio Leaf Italian Cookie – $5.00

  17. Assorted Mini Cheesecakes – $8.00

  18. Raspberry Pocket Italian Cookie – $5.00

  19. Raspberry Napoleon Italian Cookie – $5.00

  20. Pustie – $4.00

  1. 20 oz Soda – $0.00

  2. 2 Liter – $0.00

How This Menu Feels

At Tony’s Pizzeria & Sports Bar, the menu invites a balanced dining pace—whether you’re in for a quick, satisfying bite or a more leisurely meal with friends. The variety lends itself well to both sharing and solo enjoyment, creating a friendly, relaxed atmosphere where laughter and casual conversation flow effortlessly. Each dish offers comfort with a hint of excitement, matching the upbeat yet laid-back vibe of the space. The blend of familiar favorites and local specialties encourages moments of connection, making every visit feel like a comfortable pause in the day, perfect for unwinding or catching up after a game.

Menu Questions

Does Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar offer vegetarian options on the menu?
Gluten-free pasta options like Gluten Free Chicken Riggies and Gluten Free Ziti are available upon request.
Yes, the menu includes shareable items like paninis, small plates, and all-you-can-eat options which are great for groups.
Absolutely, Tony's offers both takeaway and no-contact delivery services for convenience.
Yes, there is a dedicated kids' menu and family-friendly options to suit younger diners.
  • Monday
  • Tuesday
  • Wednesday
  • Thursday
  • Friday
  • Saturday
  • Sunday
  • 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
  • 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
  • 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
  • 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
  • 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
  • 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
  • 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Where This Food Place Lives

3899 Oneida St, New Hartford, NY 13413, United States

+1 315-737-9172

FoodPlacee logo
Food Places Menus Cuisines Cities
Terms of Service Privacy Policy contact@foodplacee.com

© 2026 FoodPlacee. The place where food lives.